I don't really do oil cleansing but I have dry skin. I don't wear make up normally so I don't know how helpful this advise will be. I just rinse my face with water or a sulfate free mild cleanser and put on oil/ moisturizer of choice.
I'm not sure about the EVOO/ castor mix, I remember others complaining about the mix on the other forum. I believe most liked to have Grape Seed oil in the mix as it was light and didn't give that tight feeling.
Hope that helps.